Výsledek obrázku pro Islamic modernism and reformism
Islamic Modernism and Reformism
Islamic Political Thought (BSS474)
Josef Kraus

Background and Introduction
nHistorical reaction to „Western supremacy“
¡Response of Muslim intellectuals to European modernity
¡Reaction to salafism, fundamentalism, conservatism
nDefense and modernization of Islam towards Western institutions and social processes
¡Islam, science and progress, revelation and reason are compatible
n
nLow impact during 19th Century, catalizatin after
a disruption of Ottoman empire (WWI)
¡Promotion of secular liberalism (Farag Foda)
¡Islamic politics criticism

Background and Introduction
nAttempt to reconcile Islamic faith with modern Western values
¡Nationalism (Arabism)
¡Democracy
¡Civil rights
¡Scientific progress…
nReexamination of conceptions and methods of fiqh
nNew approach to Islamic theology and Quranic exegesis + skepticism towards hadiths

Background and Introduction
nReformism inclinates to secularism, liberalism, democracy (following Christian reformism)
n
nModernism insists on the importance of religion
in public life, but not in a form 1 400 years ago
n
nDifficult to distinguish from “salafi way” of Islamic reformism and modernism
n
nSpread among all Islamic regions

Mission of Modernist Muslim is to…
nAccording to Mir Zohair Husain
¡define Islam by bringing out the
fundamentals in a rational and liberal
manner
¡emphasize the basic ideals of
Islamic brotherhood, tolerance and social justice
¡interpret the teachings of Islam in such a way as to bring out its dynamic character in the
context of the intellectual and scientific progress of the modern world
Výsledek obrázku pro Mir Zohair Husain alabama

Main Thoughts in Isl. Modernism
nAmbivalent attitude toward the West - attraction X repulsion
nTechnology misused by the West to exploit Islamic countries can be used to strenghten Muslims
nSupport of maslahah usage
n
nReinterpretation of punishment, jihad, treatment of unbelievers, banning of interest on loans…
¡Jihad only defensive
¡Unbelief was not sufficient cause for declaring jihad
¡Preferable way of conversion is based on education
¡There is a difference between interest and usury
n

Main Thoughts in Isl. Modernism
nReinterpretation of traditional Islamic law
¡Reinterpreting of basic sources by using ijma and qiyas at standards of scientific rationality and
modern social theory
¡Limiting the influence of Quran and Sunnah on Sharia
nRadical hadith criticism
¡Employing ijtihad for critical reasoning, even approving its use by non-jurists
nIjtihad should reflect the opinion of society and meet its interests
nRejecting the closing of the doors of ijtihad
(Muhammad Iqbal, 1877 – 1938)
¡

Liberalism and Progressivism
nInterpretation and re-interpretation of traditional sources
and methods
¡Emphasis on ijtihad, abandonment of taqlid
¡
nQuranic verses interpretation in allegorical way
n
nAbsolute equality of all humanity is a basic principal
¡Conservative interpretations of Shariah in the most repressive states
¡Secular states are more open and tolerant
¡Muslim should obey the law of a state, not only religious one
n

Criticism of Modernism and Reformism
nMainly from traditionalists and conservatives
¡Blaming for atheism (ilhad) and for attempts of Westernization (taghrib) of Islam
¡Takfirism
nToo much heterogenic and vague
¡Liberal Islam, Reform Islam, Progressive Islam, Neomodernism, etc.
nNo unifying figure or movement
¡Ideal concept without any implementation in reality
n
n
n

Thank you for your attention!
Výsledek obrázku pro bright future islam