A cascade of reactions known as the foreign body response (FBR) follows the implantation of biomaterials leading to the formation of a fibrotic capsule around the implant and subsequent health complications. The severity of the FBR is driven mostly by the physicochemical characteristics of implanted material, the method and place of implantation, and the degree of immune system activation. Here we present an in vitro model for assessing new materials with respect to their potential to induce a FBR in the peritoneum. The model is based on evaluating protein sorption and cell adhesion on the implanted material. We tested our model on the free-standing films prepared from hyaluronan derivatives with different hydrophobicity, swelling ratio, and rate of solubilization. The proteomic analysis of films incubated in the mouse peritoneum showed that the presence of fibrinogen was driving the cell adhesion. Neither the film surface hydrophobicity/hydrophilicity nor the quantity of adsorbed proteins were decisive for the induction of the long-term cell adhesion leading to the FBR, while the dissolution rate of the material proved to be a crucial factor. Our model thus helps determine the probability of a FBR to materials implanted in the peritoneum while limiting the need for in vivo animal testing.