Language Number of Results BPMN 148 UML 55 EPCs 23 Declare 21 Petri Nets 15 SPEM 12 Automata 11 BPEL 11 DCR Graphs 7 YAWL 7 DPIL 6 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 148 55 Number of Results 2 3 21 „ m m 1 2 1 1 • • • • M l c / • < / ^ 4 ^ ^ Year.l Row Labels Count of Year.l 2010 2010 38 2010 2011 34 2010 2012 29 2010 2013 23 2010 2014 33 2010 2015 32 2010 2016 29 2010 2017 22 2010 2018 27 2010 2019 17 2010 2020 14 2010 Grand Total 298 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2011 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2012 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2013 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2014 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2015 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2016 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2017 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2018 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 2020 Works per Year 40 38 34 -N 29 3d. 29 29 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 22 Year BPMN UML EPC 2010 19 11 3 2011 19 6 4 2012 15 8 3 2013 11 5 2 2014 15 8 1 2015 16 0 1 2016 15 6 3 2017 11 6 2 2018 11 3 3 2019 9 1 1 2020 7 1 0 2017 2018 2019 2020 Declare Petri Net 0 1 0 2 3 4 0 1 4 0 2 0 7 0 1 5 1 1 2 1 1 0 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 Results by Year liil nn niln n 1 1n 1 1F J[Jin nnlln n n 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 202C • BPMN olIML »EPC • Declare • Petri Net ) Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A combination of business rule and m< https://www primary research yes A domain-specific language for ETL pal https://www primary use yes A formal approach to modeling and ve http://www.: primary research yes A framework to support the assignmei https://www primary extension yes A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f< https://www primary extension yes A notation for supporting social busine https://www primary extension yes A probabilistic BPMN normal form to r https://www primary research yes A Proposal for the Application of Dyna https://ieeex primary use yes A simulation tool for maintenance pro https://www primary use no Aligning the elements of the RUP/UMI http://link.sp primary research yes An approach to assessing the quality o https://www secondary research yes An empirical investigation of intuitive i http://www.: primary research yes An empirical investigation of the intuit https://www primary research yes An Empirical Study on Simplification ol https://doi.o primary research yes An evaluation framework for design-ti https://www secondary comparison yes An experimental study on the design a https://www secondary research yes An operational semantics of BPMN col https://www primary research yes Analysis and Design of Business Proce: https://link.s primary discussion no Application of business process diagra https://www primary research no Applications of Different Web Service https://ieeex primary research yes Assessing information loss in EPC to Bl https://www primary research yes Augmenting a Process Model with Stai https://www secondary use yes Behind the scenes of the BPMN extern https://ieeex primary research yes BPELvs. BPMN 2.0: Should you care? https://link.s primary research yes BPMN 2.0 and the service interaction | https://www primary research yes Bpmn 2.0 for modeling business proce https://www primary discussion no BPMN for healthcare processes https://www primary research yes BPMN Profile for Collaborative Busine https://ieeex primary extension yes BPMN4SGA: A BPMN extension for sm https://www primary extension no BPMN-L: A BPMN extension for model http://www.: primary extension yes Building orchestrations in B2Bi - The c; https://www primary discussion yes Business process modeling languages: https://link.s primary comparison no Can Business Process Modeling Bridge https://www primary discussion yes Clinical processes from various angles- https://www primary extension yes CogBPMN: Representing human-comp https://www primary research no Dealing with Collaborative Tasks in Pre https://www primary extension yes Defining the resource perspective in t\ http://www.: primary extension yes Design time validation for the correct https://www secondary research no Detecting conflicts between data-mini https://link.s primary extension yes Development of the Concept of Manai https://ieeex secondary use yes Driving time-dependent paths in clinic https://www primary transformation yes Dynamic catenation and execution of i https://www primary discussion yes Enhancing Robust Execution of BPMN https://www primary research yes Extending BPMN for supporting custor https://wwv\ primary extension yes Formal analysis of BPMN models using https://link.s primary research yes Chapter 6 - Modeling Business Process http://www.: primary research no Implementing business process recove https://www primary use yes Improved Compliance by BPM-Driven https://www primary discussion yes Integration, Execution and Monitoring https://www primary research yes Introduction to information and proce https //www primary research yes Knowledge dimension in business proc https //www secondary use yes Modeling and execution of blockchain https //www secondary transformation yes Modeling and handling duration const https //www primary research yes Modeling concepts for internal contro https //www primary extension yes Modeling controls for compliance-an i https //www primary research yes Modeling Flexible Business Processes \ https //www primary use yes Modeling security requirements in ser https //www primary extension yes Modeling Service Choreographies with https //www primary extension yes Modelling and verifying time-aware pr https //www primary extension yes Performance evaluation of business pi https //www primary transformation yes Process modeling for industry 4.0 appl https //ieeex primary use yes Refining semantically annotated busin https //www primary research yes Resilient BPMN: Robust process mode https //www primary extension no Safena and QBPM: A proposition for rr https //www primary extension yes Tackling different business process pei https //www primary extension yes The value management platform and ; https //www primary research yes Towards a Uniform Semantic Represer https //www primary research yes Towards an organizational strategic ali https //www primary use yes Towards compliance verification betw https //www primary transformation yes Towards dynamic duration constraints https //www primary research yes Towards multi-perspective modeling v https //www primary discussion yes Towards probabilistic decision making https //www primary transformation yes Towards Real World Aware Enterprise https //www primary research yes Towards simulation- and mining-basec https //www primary transformation yes Transforming PICTURE to BPMN 2.0 as https //ieeex primary transformation yes uBPMN: A BPMN extension for modeli http://www.: primary extension yes Value-chain discovery from business p https //www primary transformation yes Verification of the Consistency of Time https //www primary extension yes Weaving aspects and business process https //www primary extension yes WebBPMN: A language to design web https //www primary extension no Note BPMN4SBP extended BPMN4SGA BPMN-L CogBPMN rBPMN - rule rBPMN - rule rBPMN - resilient QBPMN uBPMN A04BPMN 2.0 webBPMN Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A framework for quality measuremen https://link.s primary research yes A Mapping Algorithm of Scientific Wo https://dx.dc primary transformation yes A mapping from BPMN model to JADE https://www primary use yes A model-guided peri-operative inform https://ieeex primary research yes Agent Process Modelling: When Multi https://www secondary use yes An approach for extracting business v http://dx.doi primary research no An empirical comparison of the usabil https://www primary comparison no An Executional Framework for BPMN https://ieeex primary transformation yes An Experience in Modelling Business F https://www secondary research yes Analyzing BPMN with extended objed https://www primary transformation yes Analyzing Critical Decision-Based Proc https://ieeex secondary discussion yes Applying process analysis to the Italiai https://www primary research yes Aspect-based realization of non-funct https://www primary research yes Aspect-oriented business process mot https://www primary extension yes BPMN extensions for decentralized ex https://www primary discussion no Business process design from virtual c https://www primary transformation yes Business process families using model https://www primary extension yes Business Process Modeling Language https://ieeex primary extension yes Configurable process modeling techni https://www primary extension no CoPModL: Construction Process Mode http://www. secondary use yes Defining and Observing the Compliam https://ieeex secondary use yes Deriving requirements model from te: https://www primary use yes Empowering business users to model https://www tertiary discussion yes Exception handling patterns for proce https://www primary discussion yes Extensible BPMN process simulator https://www primary research yes Finding the suitable process modeling https://ieeex primary comparison yes From business process models to perv https://ieeex primary research yes Impact of granularity on adjustment b https://www primary extension yes Imperative versus declarative process https://www primary research yes Implementing a transformation from 1 https://www primary transformation no Incorporating risk into business proce https://www primary extension no Is BPMN really first choice in joint arc! https://www primary research yes Lifting business process diagrams to 2 https://www primary use no MakeSense: Real-world business proc https://www primary extension yes Mapping from MAP models to BPMN https://www primary transformation yes Modeling highly collaborative process https://www primary extension yes Modeling languages for business proc http://www.: secondary use yes Modelling non functional properties ii https://www primary extension no Modelling product-service systems: Ai https://www secondary research no On the cognitive effectiveness of rout https://www primary research yes Optimisation of BPMN business mode https://www primary research no Optional activities in process flows https://www primary extension no Patterns for effective handling of exce https://www secondary use no Position: BPMN is incompatible with / https://www primary discussion yes Process design modeling with extende https://www secondary use no Process Modeling for Internet Scale Vi https://link.s secondary use yes Process Modelling in Upper Secondan https://dl.aci primary discussion yes Process-centric architecture for enter| https://www primary research no Recovering business process diagrams https://www primary transformation yes Reflecting modeling languages regard https://www secondary research no Regulatory knowledge encoding guide https://www secondary use ? SBAT: A stochastic BPMN analysis tool https://www primary extension no SBOAT: A stochastic BPMN analysis ar https://www primary research no Security checking in ABPMN https://ieeex primary research no Semantics in the context of BPMN ext https://www primary research no Service-based realization of business | https://www primary transformation yes Streamlining processes for digitalizatii https://www secondary discussion yes Suitability of BPMN correct usage by i https://www primary research yes Technical consequences of the nature https://www secondary discussion no Towards an integration of process-mc https://www primary research yes Towards business processes orchestra https://www secondary use yes Towards Modeling Real-World Aware https://doi.o primary research yes Towards simulation- and mining-base https://www secondary transformation no Use processes a€" modeling requirem https://ieeex primary use yes Utilizing time-BPMN for temporal reqi https://www primary extension no Verification of BPMN model functiona https://www primary research no Visual requirements modeling for cro: https://www secondary extension yes Visual suggestions for improvements i http://www. primary research yes Note A04BPMN ABPML C-BPMN BPMN 1.2 BPMN 1.1 BPMN4QoS BPMN 1.2 stochastic BPMN ABPMN BPMN 1.2 Time-BPMN Title Year URL Priority of Use Purpose of Use A combination of business rule and m 2013 https://www Primary Research A domain-specific language for ETL pa 2015 https://www Primary Use A formal approach to modeling and v< 2018 http://www. Primary Research A framework for quality measuremen 2018 https://link.s Primary Research A framework to support the assignme 2014 https://www Primary Extension A Mapping Algorithm of Scientific Wo 2015 https://dx.dc Primary Transformation A mapping from BPMN model to JADE 2015 https://www Primary Use A model-guided peri-operative inform 2014 https://ieeex Primary Research A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f 2019 https://www Primary Extension A notation for supporting social busin 2011 https://www Primary Extension A probabilistic BPMN normal form to 2015 https://www Primary Research A Proposal for the Application of Dynj 2011 https://ieeex Primary Use A simulation tool for maintenance pre 2013 https://www Primary Use Agent Process Modelling: When Multi 2019 https://www Secondary Use Aligning the elements of the RUP/UM 2017 http://link.sp Primary Research An approach for extracting business v 2013 http://dx.doi Primary Research An approach to assessing the quality c 2015 https://www Secondary Research An empirical Comparison of the usabi 2010 https://www Primary Comparison An empirical investigation of intuitive 2016 http://www. Primary Research An empirical investigation of the intui 2020 https://www Primary Research An Empirical Study on Simplification o 2015 https://doi.o Primary Research An evaluation framework for design-ti 2017 https://www Secondary Comparison An Executional Framework for BPMN 2011 https://ieeex Primary Transformation An Experience in Modelling Business F 2019 https://www Secondary Research An experimental study on the design ; 2013 https://www Secondary Research An operational semantics of BPMN co 2016 https://www Primary Research Analysis and Design of Business Proce 2010 https://link.s Primary Discussion Analyzing BPMN with extended objed 2014 https://www Primary Transformation Analyzing Critical Decision-Based Proc 2014 https://ieeex Secondary Discussion Application of business process diagrs 2016 https://www Primary Research Applications of Different Web Service 2012 https://ieeex Primary Research Applying process analysis to the Italiai 2012 https://www Primary Research Aspect-based realization of non-funct 2015 https://www Primary Use Aspect-oriented business process mot 2010 https://www Primary Extension Assessing information loss in EPC to B 2012 https://www Primary Research Augmenting a Process Model with Sta 2019 https://www Secondary Use Behind the scenes of the BPMN Exten 2015 https://ieeex Primary Research BPEL vs. BPMN 2.0: Should you care? 2010 https://link.s Primary Research BPMN 2.0 and the service interaction 2015 https://www Primary Research Bpmn 2.0 for modeling business proce 2015 https://www Primary Discussion BPMN Extensions for decentralized ex 2015 https://www Primary Discussion BPMN for healthcare processes 2011 https://www Primary Research BPMN Profile for Collaborative Busine 2018 https://ieeex Primary Extension BPMN4SGA: A BPMN Extension for SIT 2018 https://www Primary Extension BPMN-L: A BPMN Extension for mode 2020 http://www. Primary Extension Building orchestrations in B2Bi - The c 2012 https://www Primary Discussion Business process design from virtual c 2012 https://www Primary Transformation Business process families using model 2011 https://www Primary Extension Business Process Modeling Language 2014 https://ieeex Primary Extension Business process modeling languages: 2016 https://link.s Primary Comparison Can Business Process Modeling Bridge 2012 https://www Primary Discussion Clinical processes from various angles 2015 https://www Primary Extension CogBPMN: Representing human-com| 2020 https://www Primary Research Configurable process modeling techni 2013 https://www Primary Extension CoPModL: Construction Process Mode 2019 http://www. Secondary Use Dealing with Collaborative Tasks in Pn 2011 https://www Primary Extension Defining and Observing the Compliam 2010 https://ieeex Secondary Use Defining the resource perspective in t 2015 http://www. Primary Extension Deriving requirements model from te: 2014 https://www Primary Use Design time validation for the correct 2016 https://www Secondary Research Detecting conflicts between data-min 2018 https://link.s Primary Extension Development of the Concept of Mana 2018 https://ieeex Secondary Use Driving time-dependent paths in clinic 2017 https://www Primary Transformation Dynamic catenation and execution of 2011 https://www Primary Discussion Empowering business Users to model 2011 https://www Tertiary Discussion Enhancing Robust Execution of BPMN 2018 https://www Primary Research Exception handling patterns for proce 2010 https://www Primary Discussion Extending BPMN for supporting custo 2010 https://wwv Primary Extension Extensible BPMN process simulator 2017 https://www Primary Research Finding the suitable process modeling 2017 https://ieeex Primary Comparison Formal analysis of BPMN models usinj 2010 https://link.s Primary Research From business process models to pen, 2012 https://ieeex Primary Research Chapter 6 - Modeling Business Proces: 2011 http://www. Primary Research Impact of granularity on adjustment b 2010 https://www Primary Extension Imperative versus declarative process 2012 https://www Primary Research Implementing a Transformation from 2011 https://www Primary Transformation Implementing business process recovi 2010 https://www Primary Use Improved Compliance by BPM-Driven 2014 https://www Primary Discussion Incorporating risk into business proce 2010 https://www Primary Extension Integration, Execution and Monitoring 2020 https://www Primary Research Introduction to information and proce 2017 https://www Primary Research Is BPMN really first choice in joint arc! 2010 https://www Primary Research Knowledge dimension in business pro 2012 https://www Secondary Use Lifting business process diagrams to 2 2010 https://www Primary Use MakeSense: Real-world business proc 2013 https://www Primary Extension Mapping from MAP models to BPMN 2014 https://www Primary Transformation Modeling and execution of blockchair 2019 https://www Secondary Transformation Modeling and handling duration consi 2017 https://www Primary Research Modeling concepts for internal contrc 2014 https://www Primary Extension Modeling controls for compliance-an 2013 https://www Primary Research Modeling Flexible Business Processes 2011 https://www Primary Use Modeling highly collaborative process 2013 https://www Primary Extension Modeling languages for business proc 2010 http://www. Secondary Use Modeling security requirements in set 2012 https://www Primary Extension Modeling Service Choreographies witl 2010 https://www Primary Extension Modelling and verifying time-aware p 2019 https://www Primary Extension Modelling non functional properties ii 2013 https://www Primary Extension Modelling product-service systems: Ai 2018 https://www Secondary Research On the cognitive effectiveness of rout 2010 https://www Primary Research Optimisation of BPMN business mode 2013 https://www Primary Research Optional activities in process flows 2012 https://www Primary Extension Patterns for effective handling of exce 2018 https://www Secondary Use Performance evaluation of business p 2011 https://www Primary Transformation Position: BPMN is incompatible with / 2013 https://www Primary Discussion Process design modeling with extende 2019 https://www Secondary Use Process modeling for industry 4.0 app 2016 https://ieeex Primary Use Process Modeling for Internet Scale Vi 2011 https://link.s Secondary Use Process Modelling in Upper Secondan 2020 https://dl.aci Primary Discussion Process-centric architecture for enter| 2010 https://www Primary Research Recovering business process diagram; 2010 https://www Primary Transformation Refining semantically annotated busir 2016 https://www Primary Research Reflecting modeling languages regard 2012 https://www Secondary Research Regulatory knowledge encoding guide 2014 https://www Secondary Use Resilient BPMN: Robust process mode 2020 https://www Primary Extension Safena and QBPM: A proposition for r 2011 https://www Primary Extension SBAT: A stochastic BPMN analysis tool 2014 https://www Primary Extension SBOAT: A stochastic BPMN analysis ar 2014 https://www Primary Research Security checking in ABPMN 2016 https://ieeex Primary Research Semantics in the context of BPMN Ext 2016 https://www Primary Research Service-based realization of business | 2011 https://www Primary Transformation Streamlining processes for digitalizatii 2018 https://www Secondary Discussion Suitability of BPMN correct usage by I 2017 https://www Primary Research Tackling different business process pe 2019 https://www Primary Extension Technical consequences of the nature 2016 https://www Secondary Discussion The value management platform and 2020 https://www Primary Research Towards a Uniform Semantic Represe 2016 https://www Primary Research Towards an integration of process-mc 2012 https://www Primary Research Towards an organizational strategic al 2014 https://www Primary Use Towards business processes orchestra 2012 https://www Secondary Use Towards compliance verification betw 2015 https://www Primary Transformation Towards dynamic duration constraint: 2017 https://www Primary Research Towards Modeling Real-World Aware 2011 https://doi.o Primary Research Towards multi-perspective modeling \ 2015 https://www Primary Discussion Towards probabilistic decision making 2015 https://www Primary Transformation Towards Real World Aware Enterprise 2011 https://www Primary Research Towards simulation- and mining-base 2016 https://www Primary Transformation Towards simulation- and mining-base 2017 https://wwwSecondary Transformation Transforming PICTURE to BPMN 2.0 a: 2011 https://ieeex Primary Transformation uBPMN: A BPMN Extension for model 2016 http://www. Primary Extension Use processes a€" modeling requirem 2010 https://ieeex Primary Use Utilizing time-BPMN for temporal reqi 2012 https://www Primary Extension Value-chain discovery from business p 2014 https://www Primary Transformation Verification of BPMN model functiona 2016 https://www Primary Research Verification of the Consistency of Timi 2018 https://www Primary Extension Visual requirements modeling for cro: 2017 https://www Secondary Extension Visual suggestions for improvements i 2011 http://www. Primary Research Weaving aspects and business proces: 2014 https://www Primary Extension WebBPMN: A language to design web 2016 https://www Primary Extension Row Labels Comparison Discussion Extension Research Transformation Use Grand Total Count of Purpose of use 4 15 35 53 17 24 148 Transformation 17 Purpc 3se of Use Comparison 4 Discussion Extension 35 Row Labels Count of Priority of use Primary 122 Secondary 25 Tertiary 1 Grand Total 148 Title Year URL Priority of Use Purpose of Use Finding the suitable process modeling 2017 https //ieeex Primary Comparison Business process modeling languages: 2016 https //link.s Primary Comparison Is BPMN really first choice in joint arc! 2010 https //www Primary Comparison A Comparison of six UML-based langu 2010 https //www Secondary Comparison An empirical Comparison of the usabi 2010 https //www Primary Comparison An evaluation framework for design-ti 2017 https //www Secondary Comparison Knowledge dimension in business pro 2012 https //www Tertiary Comparison Exception handling patterns for proce 2010 https //www Primary Discussion Analyzing Critical Decision-Based Proc 2014 https //ieeex Secondary Discussion Diagram notations for mobile work pr 2011 https //link.s Secondary Use Model-driven specification and enforc 2014 http://www. Primary Extension Modeling context-aware RBAC model: 2012 https //www Secondary Extension Modeling and enforcing secure object 2014 https //www Secondary Extension Generic support for RBAC break-glass 2013 https //www Secondary Extension Concept maps for the modelling of co 2010 https //www Secondary Extension Visual requirements modeling for cro: 2017 https //www Secondary Extension Semantics weaving in aspects modelir 2014 https //www Secondary Extension Modeling support for role-based delei 2014 https //www Secondary Extension Business process design from virtual c 2012 https //www Secondary Use An empirical investigation of intuitive 2016 http://www. Primary Research Threat modelling with STRIDE and UIV 2010 https //www Primary Research On the cognitive effectiveness of rout 2010 https //www Primary Research Towards Modeling Real-World Aware 2011 https //doi.o Primary Research Aligning the elements of the RUP/UM 2017 http://link.sp Primary Research Modeling controls for compliance-an 2013 https //www Primary Research Reflecting modeling languages regard 2012 https //www Secondary Research Prover: An SMT-based approach for p 2018 https //www Secondary Research A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f 2019 https //www Primary Research Open work of two-hemisphere model 2011 https //www Secondary Research Measurement-based software proces: 2011 https //www Primary Research Introduction to information and proce 2017 https //www Primary Research Modelling product-service systems: Ai 2018 https //www Secondary Research An ameliorated methodology for desij 2013 https //ieeex Primary Research Towards a Uniform Semantic Represe 2016 https //www Primary Research On the suitability of activity diagrams 2012 https //www Primary Extension Service-based realization of business | 2011 https //www Primary Transformation Synthesizing data-centric models frorr 2016 https //www Primary Transformation Recovering business process diagrams 2010 https //www Primary Transformation Alloy4SPV: A formal framework for so 2014 https //link.s Primary Use Leveraging CVL to manage variability i 2012 https //www Secondary Use Modeling process-related RBAC mode 2014 http://www. Primary Use Architecture for a combined mobile rc 2017 https //www Tertiary Use Generating Process Diagrams for Cont 2020 https //www Primary Use Towards model-driven requirements < 2014 https //www Primary Use Use processes a€" modeling requirem 2010 https //ieeex Primary Use Patterns for effective handling of exce 2018 https //www Secondary Use Modeling and query language for hos| 2013 https://www Primary Use Specification and implementation of S 2011 https://www Primary Use Using the semantic web to define a la 2010 https://www Secondary Use Vehicle Management Information Sys 2012 https://www Primary Use Process modeling for industry 4.0 app 2016 https://ieeex Primary Use Static structure and dynamic views of 2016 https://www Secondary Use Improving natural language requiremi 2013 https://www Primary Use Towards business processes orchestra 2012 https://www Secondary Use A tool supported methodology for BPI 2010 https://www Primary Use Row Labels Primary Secondary Tertiary Grand Total no yes yes yes UML 2.0 AD yes yes UMLAD yes UML2 AD yes UML2 AD yes UML 2.4.1 yes UMLAD yes UMLAD yes UML UCD no yes yes UML 2.0 AD no UML 2.0 AD yes UML 2.2 AD yes UML2.3 yes UML 2.5 UCD yes UMLAD no UMLAD no UMLAD yes UMLAD yes UML CD yes UML static models as class diagrams yes UML UCD no yes yes yes UML 2.3 AD yes UML 2.0 yes UMLAD, UML State Machines yes UML state diagram yes UML2 AD yes UML2 AD yes UML 2.0 AD yes UML Sequence diagram yes UML Statecharts yes UML UCD UMLvl.5 UCD no Accessibility Note yes UML 2.0 AD no UMLAD yes UML v2.x AD yes UML4SPM yes no no yes yes yes yes yes no Row Label: Count of Purpose of use Compariso 7 Discussion 2 Extension 9 Research 15 Transform; 3 Use 19 Grand Tot. 55 Purpose of Use Use 19 Con Transformation 3 Researcl 15 npanson 7 Discussion 2 Extension 9 Row Label: Count of Year 2010 11 2011 6 2012 8 2013 5 2014 8 2016 6 2017 6 2018 3 2019 1 2020 1 Grand Tot. 55 Title Year URL Priority of Use Purpose of Use On the suitability of aggregated and c 2010 https://www Primary Comparison Business process modeling languages: 2016 https://link.s Primary Comparison A combination of business rule and m 2013 https://www Tertiary Discussion Dynamic catenation and execution of 2011 https://www Primary Discussion Conceptual model of accounts closing 2014 https://www Primary Extension Extending different business process r 2015 https://www Primary Extension Reflecting modeling languages regard 2012 https://www Secondary Research Towards Modeling Real-World Aware 2011 https://doi.o Primary Research Modeling controls for compliance-an 2013 https://www Primary Research Eye tracking experiments on process r 2017 https://www Primary Research Modelling product-service systems: Ai 2018 https://www Secondary Research Invigorating event-driven process cha 2016 https://www Primary Research Help is on the way - Providing User su 2017 https://www Primary Research Event-Driven Process Chain for Model 2018 https://www Primary Research Assessing information loss in EPC to B 2012 https://www Primary Research An empirical investigation of intuitive 2016 http://www. Primary Research On the cognitive effectiveness of rout 2010 https://www Primary Research Discovering business rules from busin 2011 https://www Primary Research A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f 2019 https://www Primary Research Verification of Event-Driven Process C 2018 https://www Primary Transformation Modeling languages for business proc 2010 http://www. Secondary Use On the suitability of activity diagrams 2012 https://www Secondary Use Formalizing business process specifica 2011 https://www Primary Use Accessible Note yes no yes yes no no no yes yes yes no no no yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes C-EPCs (configurable epc), aEPCs (aggregated epc) eEPC eEPC2.0 eEPC ARIS EPC Row Labels Comparison Discussion Extension Research Use Transformation Grand Total Row Label: Count of Priority of use Primary Secondary Tertiary Grand Tot. Row Label: Count of Year 2010 3 2011 4 2012 3 2013 2 2014 1 2015 1 2016 3 2017 2 2018 3 2019 1 Grand Tot. 23 Primary 78% Title year URL Priority of Use Apriori and sequence analysis for disc 2016 https //www Primary Comparing declarative process model 2016 https //www Primary Compliance Monitoring of Multi-Persf 2019 https //ieeex Primary Configurable declare: Designing custo 2012 https //www Primary Conformance checking based on mult 2016 https //www Primary CoPModL: Construction Process Mode 2019 http://www. Secondary Declarative process discovery with Ml 2015 https://www Primary Discovering metric temporal business 2014 https://link.s Secondary Discovering target-branched declare c 2014 https://www Primary Efficient discovery of Target-Branchec 2016 http://www. Primary Enhancing declarative process models 2015 https://www Primary Imperative versus declarative process 2012 https://www Secondary Improving understandability of declar 2016 https://www Primary Investigating differences between gra 2014 https://link.s Secondary Looking into the future: Using timed a 2012 https://www Primary Parallel algorithms for the automated 2018 http://www. Primary Rule mining in action: The RuM toolki 2020 https //www Primary Towards a decision-aware declarative 2017 https //www Primary Towards simulation- and mining-base 2016 https //www Primary Understanding Declare models: strate 2016 https //www Primary Using timed automata for a priori war 2014 https //www Primary Purpose of Use Accessible Note Research yes Comparison yes Use yes MP-Declare Extension yes Extension yes MP-Declare Use yes Use yes Extension yes Timed Declare Research yes Target-Branched Declare Extension yes Target-Branched Declare Extension yes Declare-R-DMN Use yes Research no Use yes Extension & Transformation yes formal ext. Of Timed Declare Research yes Use yes Use yes Transformation yes Research yes Extension & Transformation no Timed Declare Row Labels Comparison Extension Research Transformation Use Extension & Transformation Grand Total Count of Purpose of use 21 toposExtensfo Transformation 2 Transformation 1 e of Use Comparison 1 Row Labels Count of Priority of use Primary 17 Secondary 4 Grand Total 21 Row Labels Count of year Title Year URL Priority of Use Purpose of Use A combination of business rule and m 2013 https://www Tertiary Discussion A pattern based approach for structur 2012 http://www. Primary Research A pattern based approach to workflov 2011 https //ieeex Primary Research An evaluation framework for design-ti 2017 https //www Secondary Comparison Applying process analysis to the Italiai 2012 https //www Primary Research CoPModL: Construction Process Mode 2019 http://www. Secondary Use Discovering business rules from busin 2011 https //www Primary Research Eye tracking experiments on process r 2017 https //www Primary Research Imperative versus declarative process 2012 https //www Secondary Use Invariant analysis for ordering constra 2012 https //www Primary Use Modeling and handling duration consl 2017 https //www Secondary Use Modeling languages for business proc 2010 http://www. Secondary Use Reliability Prediction for Web Service 2017 https //ieeex Primary Extension Synthesizing petri nets from hasse dia 2017 https //www Primary Research Verification of Event-Driven Process C 2018 https //www Primary Transformation Accessible Note Row Labels Count of Purpose of use yes Comparison 1 yes Discussion 1 yes Extension 1 yes CPN - colored petri nets Research 6 yes Transformation 1 yes Use 5 yes Grand Total 15 yes yes yes multi-object Petri Nets yes Petri Net, Time Petri Net yes CPN - colored petri nets yes yes yes Time Petri Nets Purpose of Use Comparison 1 Discussion 1 Use / X Extension 5 1 Transformation 1 Research 6 Row Labels Count of Priority of use Primary Secondary Tertiary Grand Total Row Labels Count of Year 2010 1 2011 2 2012 4 2013 1 2017 5 2018 1 2019 1 Grand Total 15 Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A comparison of six UML-based langue https://www secondary comparison yes A pattern-based process management https://oatac secondary use yes An approach to define and apply collal https://www secondary research yes Applying AOSE concepts to model cros https://www secondary research yes Leveraging CVL to manage variability ii https://www secondary use yes Modelling software process variability https://www primary extension no On the use of model transformations 1 https://www primary use yes SMartySPEM: A SPEM-based approach https://www primary extension yes Specification and implementation of S https://www primary use no SysPEM: A SysML and SPEM based pre https://www primary use yes Transformations of software process r https://www secondary use no Using the SPEM 2.0 Kind-Based Extens https://doi.o primary extension yes Note 1.3, 2.0 SPEM2.0, CMSPEM vSPEM SPEM 2.0 vSPEM SMartySPEM SPEM4MDE SPEM 2.0, SPEM4MDE Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible BPEL remote objects: Integrating BPEL https://www secondary use yes Driving time-dependent paths in clinic https://www primary transformation yes Looking into the future: Using timed a https://www primary transformation yes Monitoring Data-Aware Business Cons https://doi.o primary use yes OBA and BORM Approach in the Orgar http://www.: primary use yes On the relevance of a business constrs http://www.: primary use yes Performance evaluation of business pi https://www primary transformation yes Semantical vacuity detection in declar. https://www primary extension yes Subject-orientation as a method to sp< https://www primary research use Using timed automata for a priori wan https://www secondary transformation no Verification of Event-Driven Process CI https://www primary transformation yes Note FSM Timed Automata Timed Automata FSM FSM FSM SAN FSM Abstract state machines Timed Automata Timed Automata Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A Mapping Algorithm of Scientific Wor https://dx.dc primary transformation yes BPELvs. BPMN 2.0: Should you care? https://link.s primary research yes Empowering business users to model; https://www tertiary discussion yes From business process models to perv https://ieeex secondary example yes Modeling controls for compliance-an i https://www primary research yes Process-centric architecture for enterp https://www primary research no Towards an integration of process-mo https://www primary research yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Applications of Different Web Service https://ieeex primary research yes BPEL remote objects: Integrating BPEL https://www primary extension yes Building orchestrations in B2Bi - The c; https://www primary discussion yes Towards an organizational strategic ali https://www primary use yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible An evaluation framework for design-ti https://www secondary comparison yes Analyzing Critical Decision-Based Proci https://ieeex secondary discussion yes CP-PMTT: A control-flow pattern basei https://www secondary use Empowering business users to model; https://www tertiary discussion yes On the cognitive effectiveness of routi https://www primary research yes Open source workflow systems https://www secondary use yes Visual suggestions for improvements i http://www.: tertiary example Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Comparing declarative process modell https://www primary comparison yes DCR-KiPN a hybrid modeling approach https://link.s primary research yes Declarative Process Mining for DCR Gr https://www primary use yes Discovering Responsibilities with Dyna https://www primary use yes Dynamic evaluation forms using declai https://www primary research yes EcoKnow: Effective, Co-Created & Con https://ieeex primary use yes Towards Low-Code Adaptive Case Mar https://ieeex primary discussion yes Note DCR-KiPN Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Comparing declarative process modell https //www primary comparison yes DPIL navigator 2.0: Multi-perspective < https//www primary use yes MuDePS: Multi-perspective declarative https //www primary use yes Simulation of multi-perspective declar https //www primary transformation yes The DPIL framework: Tool support for https //www primary use yes Towards simulation- and mining-basec https //www secondary transformation no Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Analyzing Critical Decision-Based Proci https://ieeex secondary discussion yes Developing Discrete Event Simulations https://www primary use yes Exception handling patterns for proce: https://www primary discussion yes Patterns for effective handling of exce https://www secondary use no Using simulation to evaluate error det http://www.: primary use yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A combination of business rule and m https://www tertiary discussion yes Business process modeling languages: https://link.s primary comparison no Modeling languages for business proc http://www.: secondary use yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A combination of business rule and m< https://www tertiary discussion yes A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f< https://www primary research yes Business process modeling languages: https://link.s primary comparison no Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Semantic Business Process Manageme https://link.s secondary discussion no Semantic business process modelling i https://www primary use no Transforming PICTURE to BPMN 2.0 as https://ieeex primary transformation yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible GSM+T: A timed artifact-centric proce https://www primary extension yes Modeling Uncertainty in Declarative A https://www primary extension yes Synthesizing data-centric models from https://www primary transformation yes Note GSM+T Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A notation for Knowledge-Intensive Pr https://ieeex primary research yes Evaluating KIPN for modeling KIP https://www primary discussion yes KIPO Opportunities for Interoperability https://www primary discussion yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A Metamodel Based Perspective on th https://ieeex primary research yes Developing a Process-Oriented Notatii https://ieeex primary extension yes Transferring a domain-specific semant https://www primary research yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A generic framework for flexible and d https://www secondary use yes Towards a decision-aware declarative https://www primary research yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Abstract Layers in PASS - A Concept Dr https://www primary extension yes An Editing Concept for PASS Layers https://www primary extension yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A constraint-based approach for mana https://www primary extension no Clinical processes - The killer applicatic https://www primary use yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Implementing SysPEM in the context c https://www primary use yes SysPEM: A SysML and SPEM based pre https://www primary research yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A pattern based approach for structur; http://www.i secondary transformation yes A pattern based approach to workflow https://ieeex secondary transformation yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f< https://www primary research yes Knowledge dimension in business pro( https://www tertiary comparison yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible A combination of business rule and m< https://www tertiary discussion yes Weighted-based summarization of muhttps://www secondary use yes Title URL Priority of use Purpose of use Accessible Comparing declarative process modell https://www primary comparison yes On the Analysis of C M M N Expressiven https://www primary research no Title Model URL Priority of use [POSTER] ARPML: The Augmented Re; ARMPL https //ieeex primary A collaboration process study with ap TALL https //ieeex primary A comparison of six UML-based langu Di Nitto's et al. https //www primary A comparison of six UML-based langu Chou's Approach https //www primary A comparison of six UML-based langu Promenade https //www primary A domain-specific language for model M.Q. Saleem, J.B. Jaafar, https //www primary A mapping from BPMN model to JADE AML https //www primary A methodologies and processes langu SMPML https //www primary A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f Oliveira https //www primary A Multi-criteria Evaluation Approach f PROMOTE https //www primary A pattern-based process managemenl ECPML https //oatac primary, secondary A rule-based language and verificatior Kungne, Kouamou, Tangr https //www primary A semantic framework for configurabl BPaaS http://www. primary A suite of visual languages for model-iSDL http://www. primary An extensible modeling language for t Hai, Marquardt, Theißen https //link.s primary Analyzing BPMN with extended objed EOPN https //www primary Analyzing Critical Decision-Based Procg-HMSC https //ieeex primary Applications of Different Web Service BPML https //ieeex primary Architecture for a combined mobile rc Material flow-oriented pr https //www secondary BiDaML: A Suite of Visual Languages f BiDaML https //ieeex primary Business rule based extension of a serSBPML https //www primary Comparing declarative process model EM-BrA2CE https //www primary CoPModL: Construction Process ModeCoPModL http://www. primary Critical issues of comprehensive perfo Michaela Striteska, Lucie https //link.s primary Defining and Observing the CompliamSLA language https //ieeex primary Design and development of a process Jannaber, Thomas, Vogel, https //www primary Designing continuous auditing for a hi Krishnan et al. (2005) https //www secondary Development of a domain-specific Ian Becker, Jannaber, Riehle, https //www primary Discovery and analysis of e-mail-drive Interaction Structure (IS) http://www. secondary Dynamic catenation and execution of Let's Dance https://www primary Dynamic catenation and execution of S-BPM https://www primary Dynamic catenation and execution of WS-CDL https://www primary Empowering business users to model LLPM https://www primary Eye tracking experiments on process r eGantt https://www primary Flexible Service Systems flexible process graphs https://link.s primary Formal analysis of BPMN models usinj Event-B https://link.s primary Formalizing business process specifica G-CTL https://www primary Imperative versus declarative process ConDec https://www primary Implementing a transformation from 1CSP + T https://www primary Improving the Developer Experience \ BPT https://doi.o primary Information delivery manuals to integ IDM https://back( primary Invariant analysis for ordering constra MOPN-WF-net https://www primary Knowledge dimension in business pro GRAPES https://www tertiary Knowledge dimension in business pro IDEFO https://www tertiary Leveraging CVL to manage variability i CVL https://www primary Mapping from MAP models to BPMN MAP https://www primary Metamodel based framework for info 1ST https://www secondary Mining Decision-Making Processes in Savarimuthu, Sharma, Stc https://www secondary Modeling and execution of blockchair BlockME https://www primary, secondary Modeling and query language for hos| MedMod https://www primary Modelling dependable collaborative ti DT4BP https://www primary Models of processes to organize learn PBMI'4 https://www primary Object-centric behavioral constraint nOCBC https://www primary On the suitability of activity diagrams CTT https://www primary Ontology modeling of UBL process dia UBL https://www secondary Process design modeling with extende EGs https://www primary Process model based incremental pro Edward Fischer https://www primary Process model based incremental pro V-Modell XT https://www secondary Process modeling for industry 4.0 app I4PML https://ieeex primary Process Modeling for Internet Scale Vi ISVECs https://link.s primary Process-Based Development of Compi IDFM https://www primary Product and production process modt PRODPROC https://www primary Regulated business process modeling PSD https://www secondary Research on the optimization of an arVSM https://www primary Security Concepts as Add-On for Proa RCPM https://ieeex primary Simplifying the process of identifying ' Budge, Booysen, Vosloo https://ieeex secondary Simulation of multi-perspective declai Alloy https://www primary Sisi in the ALPS: A Simple Simulation a ALPS https://doi.o primary Social specifications of business proce Azzura https://www primary Software Process Recovery: Recoverin RUPV https://www primary SP2MN: A software process meta-mo