From theory to practice: Critical points in the 2017 ILAE classification of epileptic seizures and epilepsies
Autoři
PALMINI, A., N. AKAMATSU, T. BAST, S. BAUER, C. BAUMGARTNER, S. BENBADIS, A. BERMEO-OVALLE, S. BEYENBURG, A. BLEASEL, A. BOZORGI, Milan BRÁZDIL, M. CARRENO, N. DELANTY, M. DEVEREAUX, J. S. DUNCAN, G. F. B. VACA, N. G. LOSARCOS, L. GHANMA, A. GIL-NAGEL, H. HAMER, H. HOLTHAUSEN, S. J. OMIDI, P. KAHANE, G. KALAMANGALAM, A. KANNER, S. KNAKE, S. KOVAC, G. KRAEMER, G. KURLEMANN, N. LACUEY, P. LANDAZURI, S. H. LIM, G. LORUSSO, H. LUDERS, J. MANI, R. MATSUMOTO, J. MILLER, S. NOACHTAR, O. R DWYER, J. PARK, P. S. REIF, J. REMI, F. ROSENOW, A. SAKAMOTO, S. SCHUBERT-BAST, S. SCHUELE, A. SHAHID, J. B. STEINHOFF, A. STRZELCZYK, C. A. SZABO, N. TANDON, K. TERADA, M. TOLEDO, W. V. BOAS, M. WALKER a P. WIDDESS-WALSH
Dr Fisher and colleagues have recently provided a commentary on our critique of the 2017 International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) classification of epileptic seizures and epilepsies. The commentary was disappointing in that it did not depart from their original views and suggests a lack of engagement to consider an alternative framework that might improve the ILAE classifications of epileptic seizures and the epilepsies. Epileptologists actively dealing with people with epilepsy must provide feedback and express their views on any official ILAE position, as the latter would only be valid if it succeeds in striking a balance between the perspectives of any ILAE commission and that of the practitioners. It is evident that thoughtful critiques of ILAE position papers can only be forwarded once a text is published and their directions put into use, which is what we did in our critique, in an effort to achieve the best synthesis of accumulated knowledge that could result in a practical, useful, and forward-looking classification of epileptic seizures and the epilepsies.
PALMINI, A., N. AKAMATSU, T. BAST, S. BAUER, C. BAUMGARTNER, S. BENBADIS, A. BERMEO-OVALLE, S. BEYENBURG, A. BLEASEL, A. BOZORGI, Milan BRÁZDIL, M. CARRENO, N. DELANTY, M. DEVEREAUX, J. S. DUNCAN, G. F. B. VACA, N. G. LOSARCOS, L. GHANMA, A. GIL-NAGEL, H. HAMER, H. HOLTHAUSEN, S. J. OMIDI, P. KAHANE, G. KALAMANGALAM, A. KANNER, S. KNAKE, S. KOVAC, G. KRAEMER, G. KURLEMANN, N. LACUEY, P. LANDAZURI, S. H. LIM, G. LORUSSO, H. LUDERS, J. MANI, R. MATSUMOTO, J. MILLER, S. NOACHTAR, O. R DWYER, J. PARK, P. S. REIF, J. REMI, F. ROSENOW, A. SAKAMOTO, S. SCHUBERT-BAST, S. SCHUELE, A. SHAHID, J. B. STEINHOFF, A. STRZELCZYK, C. A. SZABO, N. TANDON, K. TERADA, M. TOLEDO, W. V. BOAS, M. WALKER a P. WIDDESS-WALSH. From theory to practice: Critical points in the 2017 ILAE classification of epileptic seizures and epilepsies. Epilepsia. Hoboken: Wiley-Blackwell, 2020, roč. 61, č. 2, s. 350-353. ISSN 0013-9580. Dostupné z: https://dx.doi.org/10.1111/epi.16426.
@article{1677833, author = {Palmini, A. and Akamatsu, N. and Bast, T. and Bauer, S. and Baumgartner, C. and Benbadis, S. and BermeoandOvalle, A. and Beyenburg, S. and Bleasel, A. and Bozorgi, A. and Brázdil, Milan and Carreno, M. and Delanty, N. and Devereaux, M. and Duncan, J. S. and Vaca, G. F. B. and Losarcos, N. G. and Ghanma, L. and GilandNagel, A. and Hamer, H. and Holthausen, H. and Omidi, S. J. and Kahane, P. and Kalamangalam, G. and Kanner, A. and Knake, S. and Kovac, S. and Kraemer, G. and Kurlemann, G. and Lacuey, N. and Landazuri, P. and Lim, S. H. and LoRusso, G. and Luders, H. and Mani, J. and Matsumoto, R. and Miller, J. and Noachtar, S. and R Dwyer, O. and Park, J. and Reif, P. S. and Remi, J. and Rosenow, F. and Sakamoto, A. and SchubertandBast, S. and Schuele, S. and Shahid, A. and Steinhoff, J. B. and Strzelczyk, A. and Szabo, C. A. and Tandon, N. and Terada, K. and Toledo, M. and Boas, W. V. and Walker, M. and WiddessandWalsh, P.}, article_location = {Hoboken}, article_number = {2}, doi = {http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/epi.16426}, keywords = {epileptic seizures; epilepsies; 2017 ILAE classification}, language = {eng}, issn = {0013-9580}, journal = {Epilepsia}, note = {Editorial.}, title = {From theory to practice: Critical points in the 2017 ILAE classification of epileptic seizures and epilepsies}, url = {https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/epi.16426}, volume = {61}, year = {2020} }
TY - JFULL ID - 1677833 AU - Palmini, A. - Akamatsu, N. - Bast, T. - Bauer, S. - Baumgartner, C. - Benbadis, S. - Bermeo-Ovalle, A. - Beyenburg, S. - Bleasel, A. - Bozorgi, A. - Brázdil, Milan - Carreno, M. - Delanty, N. - Devereaux, M. - Duncan, J. S. - Vaca, G. F. B. - Losarcos, N. G. - Ghanma, L. - Gil-Nagel, A. - Hamer, H. - Holthausen, H. - Omidi, S. J. - Kahane, P. - Kalamangalam, G. - Kanner, A. - Knake, S. - Kovac, S. - Kraemer, G. - Kurlemann, G. - Lacuey, N. - Landazuri, P. - Lim, S. H. - LoRusso, G. - Luders, H. - Mani, J. - Matsumoto, R. - Miller, J. - Noachtar, S. - R Dwyer, O. - Park, J. - Reif, P. S. - Remi, J. - Rosenow, F. - Sakamoto, A. - Schubert-Bast, S. - Schuele, S. - Shahid, A. - Steinhoff, J. B. - Strzelczyk, A. - Szabo, C. A. - Tandon, N. - Terada, K. - Toledo, M. - Boas, W. V. - Walker, M. - Widdess-Walsh, P. PY - 2020 TI - From theory to practice: Critical points in the 2017 ILAE classification of epileptic seizures and epilepsies JF - Epilepsia VL - 61 IS - 2 SP - 350-353 EP - 350-353 PB - Wiley-Blackwell SN - 00139580 N1 - Editorial. KW - epileptic seizures KW - epilepsies KW - 2017 ILAE classification UR - https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/epi.16426 L2 - https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/epi.16426 N2 - Dr Fisher and colleagues have recently provided a commentary on our critique of the 2017 International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) classification of epileptic seizures and epilepsies. The commentary was disappointing in that it did not depart from their original views and suggests a lack of engagement to consider an alternative framework that might improve the ILAE classifications of epileptic seizures and the epilepsies. Epileptologists actively dealing with people with epilepsy must provide feedback and express their views on any official ILAE position, as the latter would only be valid if it succeeds in striking a balance between the perspectives of any ILAE commission and that of the practitioners. It is evident that thoughtful critiques of ILAE position papers can only be forwarded once a text is published and their directions put into use, which is what we did in our critique, in an effort to achieve the best synthesis of accumulated knowledge that could result in a practical, useful, and forward-looking classification of epileptic seizures and the epilepsies. ER -
PALMINI, A., N. AKAMATSU, T. BAST, S. BAUER, C. BAUMGARTNER, S. BENBADIS, A. BERMEO-OVALLE, S. BEYENBURG, A. BLEASEL, A. BOZORGI, Milan BRÁZDIL, M. CARRENO, N. DELANTY, M. DEVEREAUX, J. S. DUNCAN, G. F. B. VACA, N. G. LOSARCOS, L. GHANMA, A. GIL-NAGEL, H. HAMER, H. HOLTHAUSEN, S. J. OMIDI, P. KAHANE, G. KALAMANGALAM, A. KANNER, S. KNAKE, S. KOVAC, G. KRAEMER, G. KURLEMANN, N. LACUEY, P. LANDAZURI, S. H. LIM, G. LORUSSO, H. LUDERS, J. MANI, R. MATSUMOTO, J. MILLER, S. NOACHTAR, O. R DWYER, J. PARK, P. S. REIF, J. REMI, F. ROSENOW, A. SAKAMOTO, S. SCHUBERT-BAST, S. SCHUELE, A. SHAHID, J. B. STEINHOFF, A. STRZELCZYK, C. A. SZABO, N. TANDON, K. TERADA, M. TOLEDO, W. V. BOAS, M. WALKER a P. WIDDESS-WALSH. From theory to practice: Critical points in the 2017 ILAE classification of epileptic seizures and epilepsies. \textit{Epilepsia}. Hoboken: Wiley-Blackwell, 2020, roč.~61, č.~2, s.~350-353. ISSN~0013-9580. Dostupné z: https://dx.doi.org/10.1111/epi.16426.