The U.S. immigration system is characterized by fragmented policies that switch between humanitarian objectives and strict security measures, resulting in legal uncertainties and inefficiencies. This thesis promotes a bipartisan reform of immigration policies by analyzing the contrasting approaches under the Obama and Trump administrations, aiming to present a perspective that acknowledges the contributions of immigrants and the need for national security. It challenges mainstream views by highlighting the complexities beyond partisan divides, promoting a more unified and economically vibrant society.