Stress and worry in the 2020 coronavirus pandemic: relationships to trust and compliance with preventive measures across 48 countries in the COVIDiSTRESS global survey
LIEBEROTH, Andreas; Shiang-Yi LIN; Sabrina STÖCKLI; Hyemin HAN; Marta KOWAL et al.
Stress and worry in the 2020 coronavirus pandemic: relationships to trust and compliance with preventive measures across 48 countries in the COVIDiSTRESS global survey
Autoři
LIEBEROTH, Andreas; Shiang-Yi LIN; Sabrina STÖCKLI; Hyemin HAN; Marta KOWAL; Rebekah GELPI; Stavroula CHRONA; Thao Phuong TRAN; Alma JEFTIĆ; Jesper RASMUSSEN; Huseyin CAKAL; Taciano L. MILFONT; Yuki YAMADA; Rizwana AMIN; Stephane DEBOVE; Ivan FLIS; Hafize SAHIN; Fidan TURK; Yao-Yuan YEH; Yuen Wan HO; Pilleriin SIKKA; Guillermo DELGADO-GARCIA; David LACKO; Mamede SALOMÉ; Zerhouni OULMANN; Tuominen JARNO; Tuba BIRCAN; Austin Horng-En WANG; Gozde IKIZER; Samuel LINS; Anna STUDZINSKA; Muhammad KAMAL UDDIN; Fernanda PÉREZ-GAY JUÁREZ; Fang-Yu CHEN; Aybegum Memisoglu SANLI; Agnieszka E. LYS; Vicenta REYNOSO-ALCÁNTARA; Rubén Flores GONZÁLEZ; Amanda GRIFFIN; Claudio RAFAEL; Castro LÓPEZ; Jana NEZKUSILOVA; Dominik-Borna ĆEPULIĆ; Sibele AQUINO; Tiago A. MAROT; Angélique M. BLACKBURN; Loïs BOULLU; Jozef BAVOLAR; Pavol KACMAR; Charles K.S. WU; João Carlos AREIAS; Jean C. NATIVIDADE; Silvia MARI; Oli AHMED; Vilius DRANSEIKA; Irene CRISTOFORI; Tao COLL-MARTÍN; Kristina EICHEL; Raisa KUMAGA; Eda ERMAGAN-CAGLAR; Dastan BAMWESIGYE; Benjamin TAG; Carlos C. CONTRERAS-IBÁÑEZ; John Jamir Benzon R. ARUTA; Priyanka A. NAIDU; İlknur DILEKLER; Jiří ČENĚK; Md. Nurul ISLAM; Brendan CH'NG; Cristina SECHI; Steve NEBEL; Gülden SAYILAN; Shruti JHA; Sara VESTERGREN; Keiko IHAYA; Gautreau GUILLAUME; Giovanni A. TRAVAGLINO; Nikolay R. RACHEV; Krzysztof HANUSZ; Martin PÍRKO; J. Noë WEST; Wilson CYRUS-LAI; Arooj NAJMUSSAQIB; Eugenia ROMANO; Valdas NOREIKA; Arian MUSLIU; Emilija SUNGAILAITE; Mehmet KOSA; Antonio G. LENTOOR; Nidhi SINHA; Andrew R. BENDER; Dar MESHI; Pratik BHANDARI; Grace BYRNE; Kalina KALINOVA; Barbora HUBENÁ; Manuel NINAUS; Carlos DÍAZ; Alessia SCARPACI; Karolina KOSZAŁKOWSKA; Daniel PANKOWSKI; Teodora YANEVA; Sara MORALES-IZQUIERDO; Ena UZELAC; Yookyung LEE; Dayana HRISTOVA; Moh Abdul HAKIM; Eliane DESCHRIJVER; Phillip S. KAVANAGH; Aya SHATA; Cecilia REYNA; Gabriel A. DE LEON; Franco TISOCCO; Débora Jeanette MOLA; Maor SHANI; Samkelisiwe MAHLUNGULU; Daphna Hausman OZERY; Marjolein C.J. CANIËLS; Pablo Sebastián CORREA; María Victoria ORTIZ; Roosevelt VILAR; Tsvetelina MAKAVEEVA; Lotte PUMMERER; Irina NIKOLOVA; Mila BUJIĆ; Zea SZEBENI; Tiziana PENNATO; Mihaela TARANU; Liz MARTINEZ; Tereza CAPELOS; Anabel BELAUS a Dmitrii DUBROV
Vydání
Royal Society Open Science, London, Royal Society Publishing, 2021, 2054-5703
The COVIDiSTRESS global survey collects data on early human responses to the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic from 173 429 respondents in 48 countries. The open science study was co-designed by an international consortium of researchers to investigate how psychological responses differ across countries and cultures, and how this has impacted behaviour, coping and trust in government efforts to slow the spread of the virus. Starting in March 2020, COVIDiSTRESS leveraged the convenience of unpaid online recruitment to generate public data. The objective of the present analysis is to understand relationships between psychological responses in the early months of global coronavirus restrictions and help understand how different government measures succeed or fail in changing public behaviour. There were variations between and within countries. Although Western Europeans registered as more concerned over COVID-19, more stressed, and having slightly more trust in the governments' efforts, there was no clear geographical pattern in compliance with behavioural measures. Detailed plots illustrating between-countries differences are provided. Using both traditional and Bayesian analyses, we found that individuals who worried about getting sick worked harder to protect themselves and others. However, concern about the coronavirus itself did not account for all of the variances in experienced stress during the early months of COVID-19 restrictions. More alarmingly, such stress was associated with less compliance. Further, those most concerned over the coronavirus trusted in government measures primarily where policies were strict. While concern over a disease is a source of mental distress, other factors including strictness of protective measures, social support and personal lockdown conditions must also be taken into consideration to fully appreciate the psychological impact of COVID-19 and to understand why some people fail to follow behavioural guidelines intended to protect themselves and others from infection. The Stage 1 manuscript associated with this submission received in-principle acceptance (IPA) on 18 May 2020. Following IPA, the accepted Stage 1 version of the manuscript was preregistered on the Open Science Framework at https://osf.io/g2t3b. This preregistration was performed prior to data analysis.
LIEBEROTH, Andreas; Shiang-Yi LIN; Sabrina STÖCKLI; Hyemin HAN; Marta KOWAL; Rebekah GELPI; Stavroula CHRONA; Thao Phuong TRAN; Alma JEFTIĆ; Jesper RASMUSSEN; Huseyin CAKAL; Taciano L. MILFONT; Yuki YAMADA; Rizwana AMIN; Stephane DEBOVE; Ivan FLIS; Hafize SAHIN; Fidan TURK; Yao-Yuan YEH; Yuen Wan HO; Pilleriin SIKKA; Guillermo DELGADO-GARCIA; David LACKO; Mamede SALOMÉ; Zerhouni OULMANN; Tuominen JARNO; Tuba BIRCAN; Austin Horng-En WANG; Gozde IKIZER; Samuel LINS; Anna STUDZINSKA; Muhammad KAMAL UDDIN; Fernanda PÉREZ-GAY JUÁREZ; Fang-Yu CHEN; Aybegum Memisoglu SANLI; Agnieszka E. LYS; Vicenta REYNOSO-ALCÁNTARA; Rubén Flores GONZÁLEZ; Amanda GRIFFIN; Claudio RAFAEL; Castro LÓPEZ; Jana NEZKUSILOVA; Dominik-Borna ĆEPULIĆ; Sibele AQUINO; Tiago A. MAROT; Angélique M. BLACKBURN; Loïs BOULLU; Jozef BAVOLAR; Pavol KACMAR; Charles K.S. WU; João Carlos AREIAS; Jean C. NATIVIDADE; Silvia MARI; Oli AHMED; Vilius DRANSEIKA; Irene CRISTOFORI; Tao COLL-MARTÍN; Kristina EICHEL; Raisa KUMAGA; Eda ERMAGAN-CAGLAR; Dastan BAMWESIGYE; Benjamin TAG; Carlos C. CONTRERAS-IBÁÑEZ; John Jamir Benzon R. ARUTA; Priyanka A. NAIDU; İlknur DILEKLER; Jiří ČENĚK; Md. Nurul ISLAM; Brendan CH'NG; Cristina SECHI; Steve NEBEL; Gülden SAYILAN; Shruti JHA; Sara VESTERGREN; Keiko IHAYA; Gautreau GUILLAUME; Giovanni A. TRAVAGLINO; Nikolay R. RACHEV; Krzysztof HANUSZ; Martin PÍRKO; J. Noë WEST; Wilson CYRUS-LAI; Arooj NAJMUSSAQIB; Eugenia ROMANO; Valdas NOREIKA; Arian MUSLIU; Emilija SUNGAILAITE; Mehmet KOSA; Antonio G. LENTOOR; Nidhi SINHA; Andrew R. BENDER; Dar MESHI; Pratik BHANDARI; Grace BYRNE; Kalina KALINOVA; Barbora HUBENÁ; Manuel NINAUS; Carlos DÍAZ; Alessia SCARPACI; Karolina KOSZAŁKOWSKA; Daniel PANKOWSKI; Teodora YANEVA; Sara MORALES-IZQUIERDO; Ena UZELAC; Yookyung LEE; Dayana HRISTOVA; Moh Abdul HAKIM; Eliane DESCHRIJVER; Phillip S. KAVANAGH; Aya SHATA; Cecilia REYNA; Gabriel A. DE LEON; Franco TISOCCO; Débora Jeanette MOLA; Maor SHANI; Samkelisiwe MAHLUNGULU; Daphna Hausman OZERY; Marjolein C.J. CANIËLS; Pablo Sebastián CORREA; María Victoria ORTIZ; Roosevelt VILAR; Tsvetelina MAKAVEEVA; Lotte PUMMERER; Irina NIKOLOVA; Mila BUJIĆ; Zea SZEBENI; Tiziana PENNATO; Mihaela TARANU; Liz MARTINEZ; Tereza CAPELOS; Anabel BELAUS a Dmitrii DUBROV. Stress and worry in the 2020 coronavirus pandemic: relationships to trust and compliance with preventive measures across 48 countries in the COVIDiSTRESS global survey. Royal Society Open Science. London: Royal Society Publishing, 2021, roč. 8, č. 2, s. 1-33. ISSN 2054-5703. Dostupné z: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.200589.
@article{1743876, author = {Lieberoth, Andreas and Lin, ShiangandYi and Stöckli, Sabrina and Han, Hyemin and Kowal, Marta and Gelpi, Rebekah and Chrona, Stavroula and Tran, Thao Phuong and Jeftić, Alma and Rasmussen, Jesper and Cakal, Huseyin and Milfont, Taciano L. and Yamada, Yuki and Amin, Rizwana and Debove, Stephane and Flis, Ivan and Sahin, Hafize and Turk, Fidan and Yeh, YaoandYuan and Ho, Yuen Wan and Sikka, Pilleriin and DelgadoandGarcia, Guillermo and Lacko, David and Salomé, Mamede and Oulmann, Zerhouni and Jarno, Tuominen and Bircan, Tuba and Wang, Austin HorngandEn and Ikizer, Gozde and Lins, Samuel and Studzinska, Anna and Kamal Uddin, Muhammad and PérezandGay Juárez, Fernanda and Chen, FangandYu and Sanli, Aybegum Memisoglu and Lys, Agnieszka E. and ReynosoandAlcántara, Vicenta and González, Rubén Flores and Griffin, Amanda and Rafael, Claudio and López, Castro and Nezkusilova, Jana and Ćepulić, DominikandBorna and Aquino, Sibele and Marot, Tiago A. and Blackburn, Angélique M. and Boullu, Loïs and Bavolar, Jozef and Kacmar, Pavol and Wu, Charles K.S. and Areias, João Carlos and Natividade, Jean C. and Mari, Silvia and Ahmed, Oli and Dranseika, Vilius and Cristofori, Irene and CollandMartín, Tao and Eichel, Kristina and Kumaga, Raisa and ErmaganandCaglar, Eda and Bamwesigye, Dastan and Tag, Benjamin and ContrerasandIbáñez, Carlos C. and Aruta, John Jamir Benzon R. and Naidu, Priyanka A. and Dilekler, İlknur and Čeněk, Jiří and Islam, Md. Nurul and Ch'ng, Brendan and Sechi, Cristina and Nebel, Steve and Sayılan, Gülden and Jha, Shruti and Vestergren, Sara and Ihaya, Keiko and Guillaume, Gautreau and Travaglino, Giovanni A. and Rachev, Nikolay R. and Hanusz, Krzysztof and Pírko, Martin and West, J. Noë and CyrusandLai, Wilson and Najmussaqib, Arooj and Romano, Eugenia and Noreika, Valdas and Musliu, Arian and Sungailaite, Emilija and Kosa, Mehmet and Lentoor, Antonio G. and Sinha, Nidhi and Bender, Andrew R. and Meshi, Dar and Bhandari, Pratik and Byrne, Grace and Kalinova, Kalina and Hubená, Barbora and Ninaus, Manuel and Díaz, Carlos and Scarpaci, Alessia and Koszałkowska, Karolina and Pankowski, Daniel and Yaneva, Teodora and MoralesandIzquierdo, Sara and Uzelac, Ena and Lee, Yookyung and Hristova, Dayana and Hakim, Moh Abdul and Deschrijver, Eliane and Kavanagh, Phillip S. and Shata, Aya and Reyna, Cecilia and De Leon, Gabriel A. and Tisocco, Franco and Mola, Débora Jeanette and Shani, Maor and Mahlungulu, Samkelisiwe and Ozery, Daphna Hausman and Caniëls, Marjolein C.J. and Correa, Pablo Sebastián and Ortiz, María Victoria and Vilar, Roosevelt and Makaveeva, Tsvetelina and Pummerer, Lotte and Nikolova, Irina and Bujić, Mila and Szebeni, Zea and Pennato, Tiziana and Taranu, Mihaela and Martinez, Liz and Capelos, Tereza and Belaus, Anabel and Dubrov, Dmitrii}, article_location = {London}, article_number = {2}, doi = {https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.200589}, keywords = {stress; COVID-19; social psychology; compliance behaviour; trust; worry}, language = {eng}, issn = {2054-5703}, journal = {Royal Society Open Science}, title = {Stress and worry in the 2020 coronavirus pandemic: relationships to trust and compliance with preventive measures across 48 countries in the COVIDiSTRESS global survey}, url = {https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.200589}, volume = {8}, year = {2021} }
TY - JOUR ID - 1743876 AU - Lieberoth, Andreas - Lin, Shiang-Yi - Stöckli, Sabrina - Han, Hyemin - Kowal, Marta - Gelpi, Rebekah - Chrona, Stavroula - Tran, Thao Phuong - Jeftić, Alma - Rasmussen, Jesper - Cakal, Huseyin - Milfont, Taciano L. - Yamada, Yuki - Amin, Rizwana - Debove, Stephane - Flis, Ivan - Sahin, Hafize - Turk, Fidan - Yeh, Yao-Yuan - Ho, Yuen Wan - Sikka, Pilleriin - Delgado-Garcia, Guillermo - Lacko, David - Salomé, Mamede - Oulmann, Zerhouni - Jarno, Tuominen - Bircan, Tuba - Wang, Austin Horng-En - Ikizer, Gozde - Lins, Samuel - Studzinska, Anna - Kamal Uddin, Muhammad - Pérez-Gay Juárez, Fernanda - Chen, Fang-Yu - Sanli, Aybegum Memisoglu - Lys, Agnieszka E. - Reynoso-Alcántara, Vicenta - González, Rubén Flores - Griffin, Amanda - Rafael, Claudio - López, Castro - Nezkusilova, Jana - Ćepulić, Dominik-Borna - Aquino, Sibele - Marot, Tiago A. - Blackburn, Angélique M. - Boullu, Loïs - Bavolar, Jozef - Kacmar, Pavol - Wu, Charles K.S. - Areias, João Carlos - Natividade, Jean C. - Mari, Silvia - Ahmed, Oli - Dranseika, Vilius - Cristofori, Irene - Coll-Martín, Tao - Eichel, Kristina - Kumaga, Raisa - Ermagan-Caglar, Eda - Bamwesigye, Dastan - Tag, Benjamin - Contreras-Ibáñez, Carlos C. - Aruta, John Jamir Benzon R. - Naidu, Priyanka A. - Dilekler, İlknur - Čeněk, Jiří - Islam, Md. Nurul - Ch'ng, Brendan - Sechi, Cristina - Nebel, Steve - Sayılan, Gülden - Jha, Shruti - Vestergren, Sara - Ihaya, Keiko - Guillaume, Gautreau - Travaglino, Giovanni A. - Rachev, Nikolay R. - Hanusz, Krzysztof - Pírko, Martin - West, J. Noë - Cyrus-Lai, Wilson - Najmussaqib, Arooj - Romano, Eugenia - Noreika, Valdas - Musliu, Arian - Sungailaite, Emilija - Kosa, Mehmet - Lentoor, Antonio G. - Sinha, Nidhi - Bender, Andrew R. - Meshi, Dar - Bhandari, Pratik - Byrne, Grace - Kalinova, Kalina - Hubená, Barbora - Ninaus, Manuel - Díaz, Carlos - Scarpaci, Alessia - Koszałkowska, Karolina - Pankowski, Daniel - Yaneva, Teodora - Morales-Izquierdo, Sara - Uzelac, Ena - Lee, Yookyung - Hristova, Dayana - Hakim, Moh Abdul - Deschrijver, Eliane - Kavanagh, Phillip S. - Shata, Aya - Reyna, Cecilia - De Leon, Gabriel A. - Tisocco, Franco - Mola, Débora Jeanette - Shani, Maor - Mahlungulu, Samkelisiwe - Ozery, Daphna Hausman - Caniëls, Marjolein C.J. - Correa, Pablo Sebastián - Ortiz, María Victoria - Vilar, Roosevelt - Makaveeva, Tsvetelina - Pummerer, Lotte - Nikolova, Irina - Bujić, Mila - Szebeni, Zea - Pennato, Tiziana - Taranu, Mihaela - Martinez, Liz - Capelos, Tereza - Belaus, Anabel - Dubrov, Dmitrii PY - 2021 TI - Stress and worry in the 2020 coronavirus pandemic: relationships to trust and compliance with preventive measures across 48 countries in the COVIDiSTRESS global survey JF - Royal Society Open Science VL - 8 IS - 2 SP - 1-33 EP - 1-33 PB - Royal Society Publishing SN - 20545703 KW - stress KW - COVID-19 KW - social psychology KW - compliance behaviour KW - trust KW - worry UR - https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.200589 N2 - The COVIDiSTRESS global survey collects data on early human responses to the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic from 173 429 respondents in 48 countries. The open science study was co-designed by an international consortium of researchers to investigate how psychological responses differ across countries and cultures, and how this has impacted behaviour, coping and trust in government efforts to slow the spread of the virus. Starting in March 2020, COVIDiSTRESS leveraged the convenience of unpaid online recruitment to generate public data. The objective of the present analysis is to understand relationships between psychological responses in the early months of global coronavirus restrictions and help understand how different government measures succeed or fail in changing public behaviour. There were variations between and within countries. Although Western Europeans registered as more concerned over COVID-19, more stressed, and having slightly more trust in the governments' efforts, there was no clear geographical pattern in compliance with behavioural measures. Detailed plots illustrating between-countries differences are provided. Using both traditional and Bayesian analyses, we found that individuals who worried about getting sick worked harder to protect themselves and others. However, concern about the coronavirus itself did not account for all of the variances in experienced stress during the early months of COVID-19 restrictions. More alarmingly, such stress was associated with less compliance. Further, those most concerned over the coronavirus trusted in government measures primarily where policies were strict. While concern over a disease is a source of mental distress, other factors including strictness of protective measures, social support and personal lockdown conditions must also be taken into consideration to fully appreciate the psychological impact of COVID-19 and to understand why some people fail to follow behavioural guidelines intended to protect themselves and others from infection. The Stage 1 manuscript associated with this submission received in-principle acceptance (IPA) on 18 May 2020. Following IPA, the accepted Stage 1 version of the manuscript was preregistered on the Open Science Framework at https://osf.io/g2t3b. This preregistration was performed prior to data analysis. ER -
LIEBEROTH, Andreas; Shiang-Yi LIN; Sabrina STÖCKLI; Hyemin HAN; Marta KOWAL; Rebekah GELPI; Stavroula CHRONA; Thao Phuong TRAN; Alma JEFTI$\backslash$'C; Jesper RASMUSSEN; Huseyin CAKAL; Taciano L. MILFONT; Yuki YAMADA; Rizwana AMIN; Stephane DEBOVE; Ivan FLIS; Hafize SAHIN; Fidan TURK; Yao-Yuan YEH; Yuen Wan HO; Pilleriin SIKKA; Guillermo DELGADO-GARCIA; David LACKO; Mamede SALOMÉ; Zerhouni OULMANN; Tuominen JARNO; Tuba BIRCAN; Austin Horng-En WANG; Gozde IKIZER; Samuel LINS; Anna STUDZINSKA; Muhammad KAMAL UDDIN; Fernanda PÉREZ-GAY JUÁREZ; Fang-Yu CHEN; Aybegum Memisoglu SANLI; Agnieszka E. LYS; Vicenta REYNOSO-ALCÁNTARA; Rubén Flores GONZÁLEZ; Amanda GRIFFIN; Claudio RAFAEL; Castro LÓPEZ; Jana NEZKUSILOVA; Dominik-Borna $\backslash$'CEPULI$\backslash$'C; Sibele AQUINO; Tiago A. MAROT; Angélique M. BLACKBURN; Loïs BOULLU; Jozef BAVOLAR; Pavol KACMAR; Charles K.S. WU; João Carlos AREIAS; Jean C. NATIVIDADE; Silvia MARI; Oli AHMED; Vilius DRANSEIKA; Irene CRISTOFORI; Tao COLL-MARTÍN; Kristina EICHEL; Raisa KUMAGA; Eda ERMAGAN-CAGLAR; Dastan BAMWESIGYE; Benjamin TAG; Carlos C. CONTRERAS-IBÁÑEZ; John Jamir Benzon R. ARUTA; Priyanka A. NAIDU; İlknur DILEKLER; Jiří ČENĚK; Md. Nurul ISLAM; Brendan CH'NG; Cristina SECHI; Steve NEBEL; Gülden SAYILAN; Shruti JHA; Sara VESTERGREN; Keiko IHAYA; Gautreau GUILLAUME; Giovanni A. TRAVAGLINO; Nikolay R. RACHEV; Krzysztof HANUSZ; Martin PÍRKO; J. No$\backslash$''e WEST; Wilson CYRUS-LAI; Arooj NAJMUSSAQIB; Eugenia ROMANO; Valdas NOREIKA; Arian MUSLIU; Emilija SUNGAILAITE; Mehmet KOSA; Antonio G. LENTOOR; Nidhi SINHA; Andrew R. BENDER; Dar MESHI; Pratik BHANDARI; Grace BYRNE; Kalina KALINOVA; Barbora HUBENÁ; Manuel NINAUS; Carlos DÍAZ; Alessia SCARPACI; Karolina KOSZAŁKOWSKA; Daniel PANKOWSKI; Teodora YANEVA; Sara MORALES-IZQUIERDO; Ena UZELAC; Yookyung LEE; Dayana HRISTOVA; Moh Abdul HAKIM; Eliane DESCHRIJVER; Phillip S. KAVANAGH; Aya SHATA; Cecilia REYNA; Gabriel A. DE LEON; Franco TISOCCO; Débora Jeanette MOLA; Maor SHANI; Samkelisiwe MAHLUNGULU; Daphna Hausman OZERY; Marjolein C.J. CANI$\backslash$''ELS; Pablo Sebastián CORREA; María Victoria ORTIZ; Roosevelt VILAR; Tsvetelina MAKAVEEVA; Lotte PUMMERER; Irina NIKOLOVA; Mila BUJI$\backslash$'C; Zea SZEBENI; Tiziana PENNATO; Mihaela TARANU; Liz MARTINEZ; Tereza CAPELOS; Anabel BELAUS a Dmitrii DUBROV. Stress and worry in the 2020 coronavirus pandemic: relationships to trust and compliance with preventive measures across 48 countries in the COVIDiSTRESS global survey. \textit{Royal Society Open Science}. London: Royal Society Publishing, 2021, roč.~8, č.~2, s.~1-33. ISSN~2054-5703. Dostupné z: https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.200589.