2022
A New Value in Town - Data: The Other Intangibles
POLČÁK, RadimZákladní údaje
Originální název
A New Value in Town - Data: The Other Intangibles
Autoři
Vydání
ECTA Annual Conference 2022, Copenhagen, 2022
Další údaje
Jazyk
angličtina
Typ výsledku
Vyžádané přednášky
Obor
50501 Law
Stát vydavatele
Dánsko
Utajení
není předmětem státního či obchodního tajemství
Označené pro přenos do RIV
Ne
Organizační jednotka
Právnická fakulta
Příznaky
Mezinárodní význam
Změněno: 6. 10. 2023 20:41, prof. JUDr. Radim Polčák, Ph.D.
Anotace
V originále
In tangibles, value protected by property is naturally generated by demand and scarcity. We have no concept of value in the case of copyrights. It is only anticipated by the law that a work that meets certain criteria is, or might be, valuable - and then, the law wrongly anticipates that the value is generated in the same way as in the case of tangibles. There is some conceptual approach to value in patents (through the requirement of industrial applicability) or databases (through the requirement of substantial investment). We already empirically learned that the main value in data is generated through their processing. Consequently, I think that any legal protective instrument for data, if it should reflect this basic fact, cannot be property-based, but process- (or transaction-) based. I would also like to stress the (truly) conservative approach to intellectual property by pointing to the fact that intellectual property is originally designed not to provide for the ownership of respective creation or invention, but of particular rights related to them (typically use). It all means that we should focus on rights that cover processing of data (not their mere existence) when thinking about protecting the value in them - and then it does not really matter whether we speak about ‚property‘ or other rights in that relation.
Návaznosti
| EF16_019/0000822, projekt VaV |
|