Legal concept of public order: A Case for Social Representations Approach

SMEJKALOVÁ, Terezie a Markéta ŠTĚPÁNÍKOVÁ. Legal concept of public order: A Case for Social Representations Approach. In SLSA 2021. 2021.

Základní údaje

• Originální název: Legal concept of public order: A Case for Social Representations Approach
• Autoři: SMEJKALOVÁ, Terezie (203 Česká republika, garant, domácí) a Markéta ŠTĚPÁNÍKOVÁ (203 Česká republika, domácí).
• Vydání: SLSA 2021, 2021.

Další údaje

• Originální jazyk: angličtina
• Typ výsledku: Prezentace na konferencích
• Obor: 50501 Law
• Stát vydavatele: Velká Británie a Severní Irsko
• Utajení: není předmětem státního či obchodního tajemství
• Kód RIV: RIV/00216224:14220/21:00118908
• Organizační jednotka: Právnická fakulta
• Klíčová slova anglicky: social representations; public order; transgender
• Štítky: rivok
• Příznaky: Mezinárodní význam, Recenzováno

Anotace

In an ongoing project, we explore the use of social representations approach (Moscovici 1961/1976, 2008) in studying conceptualization in law. One of the concepts we explore is that of “public order”. Public order is a vague legal concept and as such it lacks legal definition and needs to be interpreted and re-interpreted in relation to context. While the interpretation of a vague legal concept is essentially in the hands of the judge making a decision, some legal concepts, such as that of “public order” have an inescapable link to social realities. In a recent case the Czech Supreme Administrative Court relied on the concept of public order when making a decision on gender indication in a person’s identification number. The court stated that for the personal identification number to bear a different than assigned-at-birth gender indication when the identified person has not yet undergone complete gender affirming surgery would be (among other reasons) contrary to public order. The argumentation leading to this conclusion shows clear argumentative as well as knowledge gaps when it comes to the steps taken to determine the content of the concept of public order, as the court practically entirely relied on personal insight of the judge making that decision. Using this research we discuss that to understand the vague legal concept of public order, law and legal academia must venture outside their traditional methodological boundaries and attempt to grasp the social complexities by any means available. Social representations approach, stemming from social psychology, offers excellent tools to do that, as social representations are essentially dynamic and open phenomena, transformed by context (Marková 2007).

Návaznosti

• GA20-10171S, projekt VaV: Název: Využití metod sociální reprezentace v analýze právních konceptů

Investor: Grantová agentura ČR, Využití metod sociální reprezentace v analýze právních konceptů